White cake with buttercream cloud decorations and a script cake topper

Custom cakes

Some celebrations call for something made just for you.

From birthdays and showers to weddings and milestone celebrations, our custom cakes are made specifically for you with the same attention to detail we’ve brought to hundreds of celebrations over the years.

Custom cakes for

  • Weddings
  • Birthdays
  • Showers
  • Milestones & Celebrations

Our process

From first idea to first slice

  1. Tell us about it.

    Complete the inquiry form with your date, serving needs, inspiration photos and anything else you’d like us to know.

  2. We’ll talk through the details.

    After confirming availability, we will work with you to develop the design, flavors, sizing and other details.

  3. Taste some cake.

    Want to try a few flavors first? Book an in-person tasting or pick up a to-go box to enjoy at home.

  4. We’ll make something beautiful.

    Once everything is finalized, our team takes it from there.

  5. Time to celebrate.

    Pick up your cake, or let us deliver and set it up for larger orders and tiered cakes.

Cake flavors

The inside counts, too.

Choose from our collection of cakes, buttercreams, and add-ins to make it your own. Or start with one of our favorite combinations.

Classic cakes

  • Vanilla
  • Chocolate
  • Almond

Specialty cakes

+$1/serving
  • Marble
  • Confetti
  • Lemon
  • Browned butter
  • Earl Grey
  • Pumpkin
  • Coconut
  • Red velvet

Classic buttercreams

  • Vanilla
  • Chocolate
  • Almond

Specialty buttercreams

+$0.50/serving
  • Vanilla bean
  • Lemon
  • Caramel
  • Coconut
  • Espresso
  • Nutella
  • Strawberry
  • Raspberry
  • Blackberry
  • Mixed berry
  • Biscoff
  • Cream cheese
  • Flavored cream cheese (i.e. cinnamon, strawberry, chocolate, etc.)
  • Peanut butter
  • Chocolate fudge

Add-ins

Additional cost varies
  • Chocolate ganache
  • Strawberry reduction
  • Raspberry reduction
  • Blackberry reduction
  • Lemon curd
  • Mini chocolate chips
  • Toffee bits
  • Strawberry crunch
  • Cookie pieces
  • Peanut butter cups
  • Fresh fruit

Four Oaks Favorites

Not sure what goes together? We’re happy to help. Some combinations are classics for a reason and we have plenty of favorites from over the years to recommend.

Ask us for a pairing

Some of our favorites

  • Strawberry Shortcake Crunch

    Vanilla cake layered with strawberry buttercream and a nostalgic strawberry shortcake crunch reminiscent of your favorite strawberry ice cream bar.

  • Chocolate Espresso

    Rich dark chocolate cake paired with silky espresso buttercream and mini semi-sweet chocolate chips.

  • Chocolate Nutella

    Dark chocolate cake and smooth Nutella buttercream dotted with mini semi-sweet chocolate chips and chocolate ganache.

  • White WeddingMost requested

    Classic white almond cake with raspberry buttercream and a raspberry reduction.

  • Browned Butter Caramel

    Fragrant browned butter vanilla cake, caramel buttercream, and toffee bits.

  • Lemon Berry

    Lemon cake made from fresh lemons with ombre layers of blackberry, raspberry, and strawberry buttercreams.

  • Earl Grey

    A light and aromatic Earl Grey cake paired with honey vanilla buttercream and topped with a light layer of fresh lemon curd.

  • Toasted Almond

    White almond cake with vanilla bean buttercream, sprinkled with sugared sliced almonds for an added crunch.

Sizing & pricing

Where your cake starts.

Every custom cake is priced individually based on its size, flavor, design and the amount of time and detail involved. Size is mostly based on how many guests you’d like to serve, and we’ll help you find the one that makes the most sense for your celebration.

Cake size Approx. servings Starting at
6" round 10–12 $55
8" round 20–25 $95
10" round 30–35 $120
5" + 7" two-tier 20–22 $135
¼ sheet (2 layer) 15–20 $70
½ sheet (2 layer) 30–38 $115

Looking for something else?

We also make smaller and in-between sizes, plus three- and four-tier cakes. Tell us what you have in mind and we’ll share pricing.

Ask about other sizes

What’s included

These prices are a starting point and include our Classic cake flavors and standard buttercream. Specialty flavors, add-ins, and design details may increase the final price. We’ll provide a complete quote before your order is finalized.

About servings

Servings are based on 1” x 2” portions and can vary depending on how the cake is cut. Serving another dessert too? Classic Pittsburgh cookie table? You may not need a slice for every guest, and we’ll help you plan the right amount.

Cupcakes

All the flavor, none of the slicing.

Cupcakes are a great option when you don’t want to deal with slicing and serving individual pieces of cake. You can choose from the same flavors as our custom cakes, all wrapped up in an easy to serve cupcake!

See cake flavors & buttercreams

Starting at

$36/dozen

Classic cake and classic buttercream, plus a custom sprinkle blend to match your theme.

  • Specialty cake flavors+$2/dozen
  • Specialty buttercream flavors+$1/dozen
  • Add-insMost +$1–2/dozen

Planning a 1st birthday party? Smash cakes are also available, starting at $25.

Inquire

Please note that custom orders require planning, especially during busy seasons. Submitting an inquiry does not automatically reserve your date. We’ll review your request and follow up with availability, pricing, and next steps.

Reviews

Kind words

Loved by our customers

You completely outdid yourself!! We absolutely loved the cake! You captured exactly what we wanted and you wouldn’t believe the comments that the cake received. Not only did it look amazing, it tasted so good! Honestly, everyone loved it and we were so happy. You were amazing to work with and you better believe I will be telling every bride out there about you! Thanks for everything!

T & MWedding cake

Emily made us the most delicious little wedding cake and three different flavors of cupcakes. They were all stunning to look at and tasting amazing! She was so easy to work with from the start, a great communicator with quick responses to my emails. She made us feel so comfortable during our tasting appointment and we could tell she really cared about creating exactly what we envisioned. We would definitely recommend Emily and Four Oaks Bakery!

EWedding cake & cupcakes

Emily was so easy to communicate with, even after I made multiple changes to my order. She took my inspiration pictures and it came out even better than I imagined. Our guests loved the different cupcake flavors and everything came out perfect. Couldn’t recommend enough!

MCustom cupcakes

Inquire

Let's talk cake

Tell us about your celebration and we'll follow up with ideas and a quote.

About you

Planning together? Add both names.

Your event

Your order

Desired products
Are you serving any other desserts?

Tell us how you’d like your servings split up. For example: a small 2-tier cake to display, with sheet cakes to serve the rest of your guests. Sizes, tiers, quantities, anything beyond the design.

The details

Theme, vibe, colors. Anything that helps us picture it.

Opens a quick upload window. No account needed.

We typically reply within 2–3 business days.

Good to know

Frequently asked questions

Can I order a custom cake online?

Sort of. You can order a semi-custom cake online by choosing from some favorite designs and customizing different elements of the cake (flavor, colors, message, etc). A fully custom order starts with an inquiry rather than a standard online checkout.

How far in advance should I place a custom order?

The more complicated the order, the more advance notice we recommend, especially for weddings and larger events. Our availability changes based on the calendar, so it’s never too early to reach out.

Do you make wedding cakes?

Yes. We offer wedding cakes, cupcakes, and supplemental sheet cakes.

Do you offer tastings?

Yes. Once we confirm availability, design, and pricing, we can schedule a tasting. We offer in-person appointments as well as a to-go option. You decide what fits best with your schedule.

Do you offer delivery?

Delivery and set-up are available for larger orders and tiered cakes. This is something that we can discuss in the custom order process on a case-by-case basis.

Do you offer gluten-free, dairy-free, or other allergy-friendly items?

We occasionally carry items made with gluten-free flours. Please contact us with your specific allergy or dietary concern. Because our bakery works with common allergens, we cannot guarantee an allergen-free environment.

What’s the best way to contact you?

For general questions, use our contact form or give us a call during our operating hours. For custom orders, please use the custom order inquiry form so we have all the information that we need.

Have another question? See all FAQs